Cognitive reframing is one of the core skills in CBT — and one of the most transformative. It teaches clients how to step back from automatic thoughts, examine them with curiosity, and replace them with a more balanced and accurate perspective.
But clients often struggle with reframing because it can feel forced, unrealistic, or “too positive.”
This guide explains how to teach reframing in a way that feels authentic, doable, and emotionally safe, even for highly anxious or self-critical clients.
What Is Cognitive Reframing?
Cognitive reframing is the process of:
- Identifying an unhelpful or distorted thought
- Examining the evidence for and against it
- Developing a more realistic alternative thought
It’s not about pretending everything is positive — it’s about seeing the situation clearly, without distortion or emotional bias.
Reframing helps clients reduce:
- anxiety
- catastrophizing
- self-criticism
- shame
- depression
- rumination
- all-or-nothing thinking
Why Clients Struggle With Reframing
Clients often say:
- “I don’t believe the new thought.”
- “It feels fake.”
- “I can’t think of anything else in the moment.”
- “My emotions are too strong.”
The problem isn’t the client — it’s the process. Reframing becomes much easier when broken into small steps.
How to Teach Reframing in 5 Clear Steps
1. Help Clients Identify the Automatic Thought
Clients need to slow down and capture the first thought that shows up before the emotional reaction kicks in.
Examples:
- “I’m going to embarrass myself.”
- “They don’t like me.”
- “I’ll fail like I always do.”
If the client says something too polished or logical, it’s usually not the automatic thought.
2. Label the Distortion
Teach clients to identify their thinking style:
- catastrophizing
- mind reading
- emotional reasoning
- overgeneralization
- all-or-nothing thinking
- personalization
This step creates distance — the thought stops feeling like an absolute truth.
Example:
“Oh, this is catastrophizing.”
When clients can name the pattern, the emotional intensity decreases.
3. Challenge the Thought Using Evidence
Help clients explore:
Evidence For the Thought
(often emotional or assumption-based)
Evidence Against the Thought
(facts, history, alternative explanations)
This is where the thought softens.
Example:
Automatic thought: “My friend is mad at me.” Evidence against: “She often replies late. Our last conversation was positive.”
4. Generate a Balanced Thought (Not a Positive One)
Clients resist reframing when the alternative feels fake or overly cheerful.
Balanced thoughts are:
- neutral
- realistic
- believable
- compassionate
- logical
Examples:
❌ “Everything will be great!”
✔ “I don’t have evidence that anything is wrong.”
❌ “I’m amazing and capable.”
✔ “I’ve handled similar challenges before.”
The alternative thought should feel grounding, not inspiring.
5. Check the Emotion Before and After
Ask the client to rate their emotion before the reframed thought, then after.
Example:
Before: Anxiety 8/10
After: Anxiety 4/10
This helps clients see the impact of reframing and reinforces the skill.
Examples of Cognitive Reframing (Therapist-Ready)
Example 1 — Social Anxiety
Thought: “Everyone will think I’m awkward.”
Reframe: “I don’t actually know what they’ll think. People are usually focused on themselves.”
Example 2 — Perfectionism
Thought: “If it’s not perfect, it’s a failure.”
Reframe: “Done is better than perfect. One attempt doesn’t define the whole outcome.”
Example 3 — Depression
Thought: “I never do anything right.”
Reframe: “I’ve made mistakes today, but I’ve also handled many things well. The truth is more mixed.”
Example 4 — Relationships
Thought: “If they seem quiet, I must have done something wrong.”
Reframe: “There are many possible reasons. I’ll check in if I need clarity.”
Example 5 — Health Anxiety
Thought: “This symptom means something is seriously wrong.”
Reframe: “It could be something simple. I’ve felt this before and it passed.”
Tips for Teaching Reframing to Resistant or Highly Emotional Clients
✔ Use “could” instead of “is”
This keeps reframes flexible, not absolute.
✔ Avoid toxic positivity
Never ask clients to “look on the bright side.”
✔ Use the client’s exact language
Reframing works best when it feels familiar to them.
✔ Pair reframing with grounding
Clients can’t think clearly when dysregulated.
✔ Encourage them to aim for 10% more balanced
Not 100% changed.
A Simple Reframing Worksheet Structure
Clients can complete this in under 2 minutes:
- Situation:
- Automatic thought:
- Distortion:
- Evidence for:
- Evidence against:
- Balanced thought:
- Emotion shift:
This pairs beautifully with your Thought Record worksheets.
Get done-for-you CBT worksheets
FAQs (Cognitive Reframing)
1. What is cognitive reframing in CBT?
Cognitive reframing is the process of identifying unhelpful thoughts, examining the evidence, and replacing them with more balanced and realistic alternatives. It helps clients reduce anxiety, depression, and negative self-talk.
2. How do you explain reframing to clients?
Explain that reframing isn’t about “thinking positively” but about thinking accurately. Clients learn to step back, examine thoughts like a detective, and choose interpretations that are calmer, more realistic, and more helpful.
3. What if the client doesn’t believe the new thought?
That’s normal. The goal is not instant belief — it’s to create a thought that feels more balanced and less distressing. With repetition, clients begin to internalize the new perspective.
4. Can reframing make clients feel invalidated?
It can — if used too early or too forcefully. Always validate the emotion first, then gently guide the client toward examining the thought. Reframing works best when it feels collaborative, not corrective.
5. Is reframing helpful for trauma?
Reframing can support trauma recovery by challenging shame-based beliefs, but it should be used carefully and alongside grounding, somatic tools, and trauma-informed approaches. It should never be used to minimize trauma.
Read more: